CromScore: 96%: Certified Cromtastic ☕
These coffees converted cream-and-sugar drinkers. Find out which one is yours.
Most coffee needs a disguise. Two sugars. Splash of oat milk. Don’t ask questions.
These don’t.
We combed through hundreds of verified Stumptown reviews looking for one thing: people who stopped reaching for the creamer. We found them.
Celia, Denver CO · Kenya Karumandi · ★★★★★
That’s not marketing copy. That’s behavioral change. Here are the three blends behind it.
The Three That Convert
Holler Mountain
4.57 / 5 · 84 reviews · CromScore: 94
Becky, Winston MO · ★★★★★
- Balanced, low acidity, not trying too hard
- Works as espresso, pour-over, French press, or drip
- The one people reorder in 5-lb bags after moving cities
- Alaska Airlines passengers track it back to this blend
- Organic, directly traded, roasted in Portland
archie01, Los Angeles · ★★★★★
Kenya Karumandi
4.5 / 5 · 8 reviews · CromScore: 91
Celia, Denver CO · ★★★★★
- Single-origin from Kirinyaga, Kenya: you taste where it’s from
- French press is the recommended brew method
- The “wait, this is actually good” cup
- 100% of reviewers who answered said they’d recommend it
- No training wheels required
Hundred Mile
4.63 / 5 · 19 reviews · CromScore: 93
JackP, Xenia OH · ★★★★★
- Organic, full-bodied, never sharp or sour
- A Blend Shuffle subscription favorite: people get excited when it shows up
- Converts single-origin loyalists who “don’t drink blends”
- Not one reviewer said they wouldn’t recommend it
- Clean record across every metric we track
The Science Behind It (Short Version)
Most grocery-store coffee is one of two things:
- Over-roasted (burnt): Bitter, ashy, needs cream to be drinkable
- Under-developed (flat): Thin and dull, needs sugar to taste like anything
Stumptown sits in the gap between those two failures: medium roast, real flavor complexity, shipped fresh from the roaster. Fresh coffee doesn’t ask for cream. It dares you to try it black.
The Rankings
| # | Coffee | CromScore | Why It Makes the List |
|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Holler Mountain | 94 | Most-reviewed, most-reordered, works in every brew method. The gateway drug. |
| #2 | Hundred Mile | 93 | Perfect record. Full-bodied, clean, converts people who “don’t drink blends.” |
| #3 | Kenya Karumandi | 91 | The flavor bomb. Smaller sample size, but the reviews are extraordinary. |
Start with Holler Mountain. Upgrade to Kenya Karumandi when your taste buds are ready. Keep Hundred Mile on deck when you want zero drama and a clean cup.
Skip the creamer.
All three are at Stumptown. We have the deals.
Shop Cromulently and Embiggen Your Savings. ☕